Kae Hwa Knowledge Center

Breathable Film Technology & Industry FAQ Guide

Knowledge Center/3. Certifications & Standards

Why Do WVTR Test Results Differ Between Testing Methods?

Direct Answer

Water vapor transmission rate (WVTR) is the amount of water vapor passing through a material under defined test conditions. The same membrane may show different WVTR values under different test methods because temperature, relative humidity, vapor-pressure gradient, specimen arrangement, and calculation procedures are not necessarily identical. A shared unit—g/m²·24 h—does not make the resulting figures directly interchangeable.

1What Does a WVTR Number Actually Represent?

A WVTR result describes moisture transfer in one specific laboratory setup, rather than an unchanging property of a material in every environment. It is useful for quality control and material comparison only when the test method and conditions are identified.

Valueg/m²·24 h
+
MethodStandard and specific procedure
+
ConditionsTemperature, humidity, vapor-pressure gradient

A WVTR figure is complete only when all three travel together.

For example, a standalone film and a film–nonwoven laminate may produce different results.

Film onlyStandalone film

One structure

The membrane alone, tested as a single layer.

Film + adhesive + nonwovenFilm–nonwoven laminate

A different structure

Adhesive coverage and added layers can influence how vapor moves through the finished structure.

2How Are ASTM E96 and JIS L 1099 Different?

ASTM

E96 / E96M

Includes gravimetric approaches that measure mass change through a specimen under prescribed conditions.

≠
JIS

L 1099

Also includes multiple procedures, including desiccant-based and potassium-acetate-based arrangements.

Different procedures impose different moisture-transfer conditions; a reported result should therefore name the specific method, not merely the standard.

Method AMethod B

There is no universal, reliable conversion factor between results generated by different procedures. A higher value from one method does not automatically demonstrate better real-world breathability than a lower value obtained by another.

3What Should Be Checked Before Comparing Suppliers?

Confirm each of the following before putting two WVTR figures side by side:

✓Standard and method designation
✓Temperature and humidity
✓Film or laminate construction
✓Test orientation, where relevant
✓Basis weight or thickness
✓Typical value or specified minimum
If a purchasing decision depends on a small WVTR difference, request comparative testing under identical conditions.

4A Practical Membrane-Selection Perspective

Kae Hwa offers microporous systems such as MicroBreath™ and monolithic hydrophilic systems such as AquaVene™. Because their transport mechanisms differ, buyers should interpret WVTR together with the properties below.

Hydrostatic resistance
WVTR
Mechanical performance
Finished-product requirements

For medical, hygiene, and outdoor applications, select a method appropriate to the end use and evaluate the completed laminate—not only the original film.

Key Takeaway

WVTR is meaningful only with its method and conditions attached. Consistent comparative testing is more useful than choosing a membrane based on the largest number printed on a technical data sheet.